Showing posts with label Class of 1953 Commons. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Class of 1953 Commons. Show all posts

Friday, April 13, 2012

The Dartmouth: SA Candidates talk Greek issues

(Even though they didn't report on any of my thoughtful remarks) shared from The Dartmouth:
Student Assembly presidential and vice-presidential candidates participated in the third of four scheduled debates at Sigma Delta sorority on Thursday night, discussing the aspects of the Greek system that they think make it essential to campus life as well as ways they would seek to improve it in the future.

Most of the debate's questions were directed to presidential candidates Max Hunter '13, Suril Kantaria '13, Erin Klein '13, J.T. Tanenbaum '13 and Rachel Wang '13, though vice-presidential candidates Julia Danford '13, Troy Dildine '13, Sahil Joshi '13, James Lee '13 and Callista Womick '13 also took part.

Shortly after the debate concluded, Lee announced his decision to withdraw from the race.

"Having reflected and talked to various people and friends, I've started to see what I want my senior year to look like," Lee said. "I no longer feel that the vice president position is in my best interest."

Thursday's debate was hosted by the Greek Leadership Council. The debate moderators, former Panhellenic Council president Ellie Sandmeyer '12 and Greek Leadership Council moderator Duncan Hall '13, asked the candidates about the role of Greek life on campus and their ideas to address the problems of exclusion, binge drinking, sexual assault and violence associated with the Greek system.

Greek organization presidents asked the candidates questions in person or submitted their questions to the moderators before the event, and there was a brief opportunity for the audience to ask questions at the end of the debate. By the debate's 6 p.m. start time, the audience filled the first floor seating of Sigma Delt, and latecomers were forced to stand in the back or crowd the entryway.

All five of the presidential candidates are affiliated with a fraternity or sorority, while three of the five vice-presidential candidates identified themselves as affiliated.

The presidential candidates agreed that Greek organizations provide a social space for affiliated and unaffiliated students to enjoy and create strong bonds between members. While they said that the fundamental system is not flawed, candidates argued that there needs to be an emphasis on increasing accountability, transparency and respect among those who choose to participate in Greek life.

"We need to ensure that we're staying true to the values of community," Klein said. "We should award houses for having the highest [grade point averages] and philanthropy hours."

Presidential candidates were careful to note the Assembly's limited jurisdiction in dealing with the problems in the Greek system and instead emphasized the need for house leadership to take on these tasks.

Hunter, Kantaria and Wang advocated for more sorority houses on campus to make the Greek system less male-dominated. Klein disagreed, arguing that the solution to the problems created by gender-specific spaces would not be solved by creating more of these spaces. Tanenbaum focused on the need to increase ongoing education within the houses about these issues, a focus that other candidates then jumped to affirm as well.

Hunter emphasized the problems posed by national sororities, which do not allow open parties for the whole community to attend.

"We need to get rid of the ridiculous ban on local sororities and support more physical plants for new houses," he said.

Wang argued for more non-Greek spaces such as the one currently being designed in the basement of the Class of 1953 Commons and discouraged her fellow candidates from labeling these spaces "alternative."

Hunter, however, argued that Wang's plan would probably not work because these spaces will not attract students under the legal drinking age.

When the presidential candidates were asked about what aspect of the Greek system they would change, the candidates generally agreed that Greek houses should increase their mechanisms for internal accountability. The candidates noted, however, that administrative positions are already in place for Greek system oversight.

"It's not the role for [the Assembly] to govern the Greek system," Tanenbaum said. "We need to get the GLC, [Inter-Fraternity Council] and Panhell more involved in individual houses through using outreach to work with Greek students and emphasizing education programs."

Kantaria stressed similar points and said that Greek houses should focus on developing their own standards for acceptable behavior by establishing a code of conduct within their house.

Klein was alone in suggesting that the Assembly play a part in applying social pressure to Greek organizations that have a record of breaking College policy instead of relying on existing Greek policies and general College administrators.

Klein's suggestion was met with rebuttals from Hunter and Tanenbaum.

The candidates agreed that the Assembly could play a greater role in advertising the variety of Greek organizations on campus, citing the limited information that freshmen received about houses that were not seen as being "mainstream."

Kantaria took this point further by emphasizing his plan to have liaisons from various Greek organizations attend Assembly meetings a suggestion that other candidates compared to a similar, failed plan by former Assembly President Eric Tanner '11.

Instead of establishing liaison positions, Tanenbaum discussed the need to increase communication and dialogue among Greek organization leaders.

"We need to come together to talk about issues we all face," Tanenbaum said. "I've talked to a lot of people in leadership positions, and they say that they don't feel like they know anyone else running groups across campus."

Candidates were asked how they would react if they found a letter describing plans for future hazing by a student group on campus. Wang, Kantaria and Klein said that they would quickly take action to contact the relevant group's leader to follow up on the situation.

Hunter and Tanenbaum said they would be careful to try to understand the context of the situation before acting.

"On paper, hazing looks very black and white," Hunter said. "But hazing is not a catch-all. It's not about wearing funny clothes."

Tanenbaum said that any member of the College community, not just the Assembly president, should be impelled to act in such a situation.

Upon resigning, Lee said that the other candidates all "bring their own capabilities to the table." Although he has not decided to endorse a candidate, Lee said that experience on the Assembly will be especially important to a successful presidency.

"The candidates need to critically examine the proposals that they have made to see if they are feasible within [the Assembly] and can be met in their three terms," Lee said. "Given the general lack of [Assembly] experience, it's even more important that a presidential candidate have experience because its likely he is going to need to train his VP."

Thursday, April 12, 2012

The Dartmouth: Assembly hosts first of debates

Shared from The Dartmouth:

Photo by Nathan Yeo | Callista Womick 5th from Right
Student Assembly presidential and vice-presidential candidates participated in the first of four scheduled debates on Tuesday, focusing their discussion on the Assembly's inefficiencies and their plans to address them.

Presidential candidates Max Hunter '13, Suril Kantaria '13, Erin Klein '13, J.T. Tanenbaum '13 and Rachel Wang '13 and vice-presidential candidates Julia Danford '13, Troy Dildine '13, Sahil Joshi '13, James Lee '13 and Callista Womick '13 attended the debate.

Elise Smith '13, who did not attend the debate, said she has withdrawn from the presidential race. She said she rescinded her candidacy after determining that the Assembly is not the best "outlet" for her to effect change on campus.

Smith said she "deeply cares" about the Dartmouth community and plans to continue to address issues that affect the student body. She has not endorsed another candidate at this time.

The debate began with short introductions by the candidates, who described their activities on campus. During the question-and-answer portion of the debate, each presidential and vice-presidential candidate was given 35 seconds to answer questions posed by either audience members or the moderators, Ben Ludlow '12 and Rohail Premjee '14. Candidates also had the option of providing 15-second rebuttals.

The presidential candidates all said the role of president has not been effectively used to represent the entire student body and suggested a number of ways to rectify this problem.

Klein said she hopes to hold "leadership summits" that bring together community leaders from across campus to form "community standards" and recommendations for the administration, while Hunter said that student satisfaction should be "paramount" to administrative decision-making.

"We need to continue saying we are not satisfied until the administration listens," Hunter said.

Wang said that the Assembly must increase transparency in order to bring "information back to the students." The Assembly should hold office hours and update its website more frequently, she said.

Tanenbaum said he plans to reach out to campus groups and use the Assembly as a forum to advocate for their needs. The current practice of asking representatives to attend Assembly meetings has not worked in the past, he said.

"We need to say, We're going to send representatives to you,'" he said.

Kantaria disagreed with Tanenbaum's proposal and said that the small size of the Assembly would place an undue burden on its members if they were required to attend campus group meetings.

A campus-wide survey to gather student opinions on changes made to the dining plan was the Assembly's greatest accomplishment this year, according to Hunter, Wang and Kantaria, though Hunter said the Assembly could have more thoroughly addressed the results and pressured the administration to enact real change.

The Assembly should seek to improve its advocacy in order to "actually get change to happen," Wang said.

Klein said the Assembly's greatest strength is its potential to be used as a mechanism for support and advocacy, a potential that it is not currently utilizing effectively.

Tanenbaum said the Assembly's greatest achievement has been its increased effort to collaborate with the administration. Hunter, however, argued that the administration had not effectively responded to student feedback.

In response, Klein said that "it's easy to keep blaming our administration" for the problems the student body is facing, but many student issues, such as sexual assault and hazing, must be tackled by students.

Wang also said that "a lot of the responsibility is on us," noting that the student body must also be held accountable for campus issues.

Whereas the president focuses his or her attention outward, the vice president is most responsible for the internal organization of the Assembly, vice-presidential candidates said.

The vice president should actively reach out to student groups "on their ground" to get them more involved in the Assembly, Womick said.

"We don't really have an active [Assembly]," she said. "People don't really take it seriously. They don't go to it."

Lee said that the key role of the vice president is to "look internally" at the organization of the Assembly to consider where change is necessary. Lee's experience as a member of the Assembly since his freshman year places him in the best position to "effectualize that promise," he said.

Danford emphasized the importance of membership both obtaining and retaining members in the Assembly. The vice president should be "friendly and outgoing" in order to make people comfortable, she said.

Dildine agreed that the vice president needs to establish a community within the Assembly to ensure that the environment is "fun and safe." The vice president should also play a role in ensuring that there are voting representatives from each campus organization present at meetings, he said.

Joshi said he agreed with the other candidates' sentiment that the Assembly has been ineffective thus far. Many Assembly committees are unnecessary because similar, more effective organizations already exist, he said.

"There's a lot of redundancy in what [the Assembly] does and what a lot of campus organizations do," he said.

Presidential and vice-presidential candidates also said that the Assembly has not been using its budget effectively.

The organization spends money on "silly, frivolous things" like excessive food at poorly attended meetings, and it still maintains a $40,000 budget surplus, Klein said.

Wang, who said her work on the Council on Student Organizations has made her "passionate" about the budget, said the Assembly should spend money on areas of campus that currently lack funding.

Following the debate, all five presidential candidates said they were satisfied but noted the difficulty of the time constraints posed by the large number of candidates.

"I think that with so many candidates, it's difficult for everyone to have a significant amount of time to address the questions," Kantaria said. "It was often difficult to express all my thoughts."

Hannah Decker '13, who attended the debate to support Kantaria and Danford and out of "general interest" in the other candidates, said she was happy to see so many candidates attend the debate, even if the number is "a little unwieldy."

"I actually think it's really powerful," she said. "It's inspiring that so many students want to take a leadership role."

She said the debate's focus on the "dysfunctional" nature of the Assembly, rather than on the candidates and concrete issues, was disappointing.

Patrick Campbell '15, an active member of the Assembly, said he would have preferred to hear more "specific" ideas instead of the broad goals outlined by the candidates, though the nature of the candidates' statements was influenced by the time restrictions.

The debate, sponsored by the Assembly and the Elections Planning and Advisory Committee, was held in Paganucci Lounge in the Class of 1953 Commons on Tuesday afternoon. The Afro-American Society and Inter-Community Council will host a diversity-focused debate tonight at 6:30 p.m. in Cutter-Shabazz Hall. A third debate will be held on Thursday night, and The Dartmouth will host a debate on Friday. Voting will take place on Monday, April 16 from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.

Thursday, March 31, 2011

Scene Sixty-Five: Dartmouth Gets Greener

Our recycling system is ok.

We now have single-stream and there are bins beside most trash cans, but the system isn't uniform across campus and many students are too confused (or too apathetic) to utilize it.

Collis Cafe took a step toward addressing that this term with not only the addition of a compost option (previously available only at foco*) but also a complete revamping of the system which makes the distinction between receptacles much more obvious. Kudos to whoever took the initiative.

In other news, I saw the first flowers of the season today: crocuses, yellow and purple. I hope they'll be hardy enough to stand the snow tomorrow.


Crocuses
© Copyright Callista Womick 2011

*Comments on the renovation: I miss the beautiful murals on the old foco ceiling (although apparently they contained asbestos) and having only one entrance/exit (as of this term) is a pain, but I guess the pirate theme is pretty cool. Seriously, though: I heard some people referring to it as '53 yesterday. The distinction between Thayer Dining Hall and Thayer Engineering School was admittedly dodgy sometimes, but there's nothing ambiguous about foco. Lest the old traditions fail.

*** Update 1 (3 Aug. 2012): RIP Home Plate.